A plea to FbodyFather
#33
Umm, as bad as the plugs/wires are to do on a 4th-gen (and keep in mind, they DID get EASIER with the LS1, compared to the LT1! ) ..... are they not a lot easier to do than just about ANY average FWD V6 out on the market??? And maybe not so much FWD CARS, but think of all the V6 MINI-VANS!!! I know on some vans like that, pretty much the "easiest" way to change the back 3 plugs is to cut the exhaust pipe (as well as pull the motor mounts, etc.) to roll the motor forward. But yeah, think of the work going into THAT plug change!!
I agree whole-heartedly that changing the plugs on our 4th-gens is a b!tch. BUT, having done it a couple times now, I've actually found that a little "experience" has made the job easier and easier to do each successive time. I think that leads to the argument of taking the car to your "authorized GM service center", where they are used to working on their own product, and can complete these gruesome tasks with a degree of "ease", compared to the average back-yard mechanic Joe Car-nut .
Just speaking from the realistic side of things, although I too wish the car wasn't so hard to work on sometimes (like the bleeder screw for the clutch!!! Damn you!!!!! ).
I agree whole-heartedly that changing the plugs on our 4th-gens is a b!tch. BUT, having done it a couple times now, I've actually found that a little "experience" has made the job easier and easier to do each successive time. I think that leads to the argument of taking the car to your "authorized GM service center", where they are used to working on their own product, and can complete these gruesome tasks with a degree of "ease", compared to the average back-yard mechanic Joe Car-nut .
Just speaking from the realistic side of things, although I too wish the car wasn't so hard to work on sometimes (like the bleeder screw for the clutch!!! Damn you!!!!! ).
#34
I haven't read all of the posts in this thread but the LS2 and later engines
are quite different from the LS1. The LS1 in my '04 GTO had hoses everywhere the LS2 has so much room around it that I can put my foot alongside the engine and touch the framerails.
As long as GM doens't rake th windshield back too far and have the cowl
come over the engine everything should be fine.
I wish I could post pics so you guys can see that the plugs are readily accessible.
are quite different from the LS1. The LS1 in my '04 GTO had hoses everywhere the LS2 has so much room around it that I can put my foot alongside the engine and touch the framerails.
As long as GM doens't rake th windshield back too far and have the cowl
come over the engine everything should be fine.
I wish I could post pics so you guys can see that the plugs are readily accessible.
#35
In all honesty, the first few times I did these changes, it was a major PITA until made the decision to go ahead and remove what was in the way.
IOW, most of these complaints are because people want to go directly to the plugs and not spend the few minutes to remove things like starters and alternators on LT1's and coil packs on LS1's....that and having the right tools for the job.
It doesn't take any longer to remove these items as it does to loose a knuckle of layer of skin trying to shortcut the process.
Working on an LS1 car is LIGHT YEARS ahead of working on an LT1 car, so they are making great strides towards making it easier to work on.
IOW, most of these complaints are because people want to go directly to the plugs and not spend the few minutes to remove things like starters and alternators on LT1's and coil packs on LS1's....that and having the right tools for the job.
It doesn't take any longer to remove these items as it does to loose a knuckle of layer of skin trying to shortcut the process.
Working on an LS1 car is LIGHT YEARS ahead of working on an LT1 car, so they are making great strides towards making it easier to work on.
short answer no. Infact for my 3.0 2002 Accord front drive V6 its an allen wrench and then the plugs to both sides are easily accessable. I plan on knocking it out first chance I get in a parking lot. Dont expect more than a couple minutes once the motor cools...
#36
I haven't read all of the posts in this thread but the LS2 and later engines
are quite different from the LS1. The LS1 in my '04 GTO had hoses everywhere the LS2 has so much room around it that I can put my foot alongside the engine and touch the framerails.
As long as GM doens't rake th windshield back too far and have the cowl
come over the engine everything should be fine.
I wish I could post pics so you guys can see that the plugs are readily accessible.
are quite different from the LS1. The LS1 in my '04 GTO had hoses everywhere the LS2 has so much room around it that I can put my foot alongside the engine and touch the framerails.
As long as GM doens't rake th windshield back too far and have the cowl
come over the engine everything should be fine.
I wish I could post pics so you guys can see that the plugs are readily accessible.
#37
Haven't owned a 4th gen, but I didn't change the factory plugs and wires in my Silverado until 102K. Truck ran no different than it did when it was new and the plugs were very clean. They were about 7 years old at the time I changed them.
#38
Did you check the gap? Larger gaps retard timing.
#41
to answer your question it did work the first time. for a few months (about 8 months or so) and it was another tech who did the work. Granted I was ripped off. 200 per O2 sensor and another 200 for labor but thats beside the point. banks 1 and 2 of my 3800 were what was tripping the alert and it knocked the light out for about 8 months. I changed them on my own for $50 a pop from gmparts direct with authentic gm parts two different times after. I also tried Bosch O2 sensors from Autozone for 60 and each time it was a one handed job. each time it only knocked it out for a 2-3 months.
Now I relize my skills may be lacking to do doing the same thing the tech I paid to do the first time did. Also he put in a set of plugs for 200 in labor which I also did about a year later. Before I sold this wonderful machine at 240k miles or so I had a GM dealer put in a set of wires for $200 for the 3rd time since I bought it at 80k miles.
You can say whatever you like about me but I came to HATE that car. I didnt know that O2 sensor problems were so common that there are after market simulators and have seen simulators as suggested fixes in different forum threads as a soloution..
Now I relize my skills may be lacking to do doing the same thing the tech I paid to do the first time did. Also he put in a set of plugs for 200 in labor which I also did about a year later. Before I sold this wonderful machine at 240k miles or so I had a GM dealer put in a set of wires for $200 for the 3rd time since I bought it at 80k miles.
You can say whatever you like about me but I came to HATE that car. I didnt know that O2 sensor problems were so common that there are after market simulators and have seen simulators as suggested fixes in different forum threads as a soloution..
Fix what's causing the O2's to foul out and you won't have to change them so often as they really shouldn't need to be changed but maybe once or twice in the 240k mile lifetime.
#42
What I was really trying to convey is that I DONT want to remove starters or Y pipes or drop the motor as has been suggested to do the simplest work on the car. I dont want to pay someone hundreds of dollars more to do work because some engineer or exec didnt think that good engineering was a freaking good idea. Also if I bought a car and the first thing it needed were plugs that cost my $200 in labor alone as soon as I got it, you can bet Id utter the phrase "never again" or "Ill never buy another one" as I sign the bill standing across from a tech who isnt happy with me because I brought him this POS to work on. Something that has happened.
Theres nothing to be gained here. The 5th will be easier to work on. You can see it from the engine bay shots where the windshield falls short. Id bet you could probably get to it from the top even. Over hang isnt nearly as long reducing the amount of car you have to crawl under to simply change the oil. Also helpful when using ramps. GM seems to have realized their mistakes, and corrected them it seems. Thats all that matters. I see this as what killed the car, and why Mustang out sold it by so much. If it wasnt for the drive train it would have been a turkey shoot. You disagree. Thats fine.
Last edited by 5thgen69camaro; 10-15-2007 at 07:22 PM.
#45
The guys insinuating that I wouldn't have as hard of a time with it if I had a little more experience with changing them are really cracking me up Ummm, I've owned/worked on 4th gens for 13 years now, and BELIEVE me the LT1 with stock manifolds was worse than the LS1. I put headers on originally for the plug access ALONE, and have since built three more engines for the 95. My 02 SS is bone stock and shall remain so (other than I'm relocating the coil packs now after this last round of bloody knuckles).
Some of you guys are missing my point with this whole diatribe though. I want GM to be at the top of the market. I want to be proud of every aspect of the car, not just a great engine and the bang for the buck. All I'm asking for is GM to step up to the plate in the tiniest amount to make this next car a standout. If it has great/decent/good access to the stuff that the manufacturer requires me to maintain, then great! I'm just voicing my desires here with hope that SOMEONE at GM might hear it and some sort of dialog might happen in a design meeting. Probably wishful thinking on my part, but it's there nontheless.
OBTW, the day I pay someone 200 bucks to change the plugs on any of my cars is the day I turn in my man card and go have a nice quiche.
Some of you guys are missing my point with this whole diatribe though. I want GM to be at the top of the market. I want to be proud of every aspect of the car, not just a great engine and the bang for the buck. All I'm asking for is GM to step up to the plate in the tiniest amount to make this next car a standout. If it has great/decent/good access to the stuff that the manufacturer requires me to maintain, then great! I'm just voicing my desires here with hope that SOMEONE at GM might hear it and some sort of dialog might happen in a design meeting. Probably wishful thinking on my part, but it's there nontheless.
OBTW, the day I pay someone 200 bucks to change the plugs on any of my cars is the day I turn in my man card and go have a nice quiche.
Last edited by CCCCCYA; 10-15-2007 at 09:02 PM.