Automotive News / Industry / Future Vehicle Discussion Automotive news and discussion about upcoming vehicles
View Poll Results: Which one to use on 5th Gen?
Trunk
43
52.44%
Hatch
39
47.56%
Voters: 82. You may not vote on this poll

Trunk vs. Hatch, Which one to use on 5th Gen?

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
Old 07-12-2005 | 03:32 PM
  #16  
KillerTA's Avatar
Registered User
 
Joined: Dec 1999
Posts: 1,119
Re: Trunk vs. Hatch, Which one to use on 5th Gen?

TRUNK I don't put too much in the back for fear of scratching the hell out interior panels plus everone can see what's in the back. The well doesn't hold much stuff either and the surfaces are irregular.

A trunk is usually rectangular, you can't see in it, and the back seat would probably fold down too which would allow you to store even more stuff. You don't have to worry about tearing up your interior either.
Old 07-12-2005 | 03:59 PM
  #17  
85LT1Z28MEX's Avatar
Registered User
 
Joined: Dec 2002
Posts: 133
From: Mexico
Re: Trunk vs. Hatch, Which one to use on 5th Gen?

HATCH-..

I don´t mind that the shocks can´t lift it as long as can keep it up..

When I take the car to the strip, I put the slicks in, gas jug, tools, an extra full size tire, jack, cooler box, helmet, I don´t think all this will fit in a trunk..
Old 07-12-2005 | 04:24 PM
  #18  
Brandon_Lutz's Avatar
Registered User
 
Joined: Feb 2005
Posts: 301
From: Alexandria, Louisiana
Re: Trunk vs. Hatch, Which one to use on 5th Gen?

TRUNK!!
Old 07-12-2005 | 04:48 PM
  #19  
muckz's Avatar
Registered User
 
Joined: Oct 2000
Posts: 2,402
From: Toronto, ON Canada
Re: Trunk vs. Hatch, Which one to use on 5th Gen?

Definitely hatch. Not only does it provide a sleek look, it is very practical.

Where else would i be able to put my mountain bike without taking the wheel off? I put the seats down, and there is a large cargo area for stuff like bikes.

Also, when I bought Z06 replica rims for my Z, all four boxes fit nicely in through the back. Try putting something large and heavy into the back seat of a coupe.

As for structure rigidity, just get an aftermarket company to manufacture a rear brace (liek the front strut brace, but for the rear).
Old 07-12-2005 | 04:57 PM
  #20  
jg95z28's Avatar
Registered User
 
Joined: Sep 2002
Posts: 9,710
From: Oakland, California
Re: Trunk vs. Hatch, Which one to use on 5th Gen?

Originally Posted by muckz
Definitely hatch. Not only does it provide a sleek look, it is very practical.

Where else would i be able to put my mountain bike without taking the wheel off? I put the seats down, and there is a large cargo area for stuff like bikes.

Also, when I bought Z06 replica rims for my Z, all four boxes fit nicely in through the back. Try putting something large and heavy into the back seat of a coupe.

As for structure rigidity, just get an aftermarket company to manufacture a rear brace (liek the front strut brace, but for the rear).
Dude, you need an SUV not a ponycar.
Old 07-12-2005 | 05:11 PM
  #21  
Joe K. 96 Zeee!!'s Avatar
Registered User
 
Joined: Dec 2001
Posts: 1,531
Re: Trunk vs. Hatch, Which one to use on 5th Gen?

Originally Posted by jg95z28
Dude, you need an SUV not a ponycar.
I understand the sentiment and even though you're joking, many of us can only afford one car. We want a performance car, but still need a little practicality. My Camaro's have done an excellent job in not only providing superior performance, but also hauling stuff some ordinary cars wouldn't be able to hold. Heck I fit all 4 new tires from tirerack in the back of my car when I went to Firestone to have them mounted.
Old 07-12-2005 | 05:13 PM
  #22  
jg95z28's Avatar
Registered User
 
Joined: Sep 2002
Posts: 9,710
From: Oakland, California
Re: Trunk vs. Hatch, Which one to use on 5th Gen?

Actually I wasn't joking. Just because someone can't afford two cars, or can't afford an performance SUV, doesn't justify screwing it up for everyone else.
Old 07-12-2005 | 05:17 PM
  #23  
poSSum's Avatar
Disciple
 
Joined: Dec 2000
Posts: 1,479
Re: Trunk vs. Hatch, Which one to use on 5th Gen?

Gotta say trunk. I can't picture a hatchback convertible.

I like the idea of the structural integrity and noise control a trunk would offer the coupe.

Sounds like a 5th gen based Nomad is the ticket for the 1 car crowd here.
Old 07-12-2005 | 05:18 PM
  #24  
Joe K. 96 Zeee!!'s Avatar
Registered User
 
Joined: Dec 2001
Posts: 1,531
Re: Trunk vs. Hatch, Which one to use on 5th Gen?

Originally Posted by jg95z28
Actually I wasn't joking. Just because someone can't afford two cars, or can't afford an performance SUV, doesn't justify screwing it up for everyone else.
Eh...Who says it would screw it up for everyone else? All I'm saying is that practicality shouldn't be totally ignored. If they can do it with a trunk, then fine. Heck, a lot of arguments for a trunk are for practicality too!
Old 07-12-2005 | 05:20 PM
  #25  
muckz's Avatar
Registered User
 
Joined: Oct 2000
Posts: 2,402
From: Toronto, ON Canada
Re: Trunk vs. Hatch, Which one to use on 5th Gen?

Originally Posted by jg95z28
Actually I wasn't joking. Just because someone can't afford two cars, or can't afford an performance SUV, doesn't justify screwing it up for everyone else.
Define "screwing it up". Your preferance for a trunk is screwing it up for everyone else. By the looks of the poll, it's a 50-50 split.
Old 07-12-2005 | 05:21 PM
  #26  
notgetleft's Avatar
Registered User
 
Joined: Jun 2001
Posts: 808
From: manassas, VA
Re: Trunk vs. Hatch, Which one to use on 5th Gen?

Originally Posted by jwade95Z
Trunk, absolutely.

Security of passengers and cargo. Nothing like having your cargo hit you in the back of the head at 30 - 70 mph.
I'm with this guy.


I like all the responses about "one time i picked up a roll of flooring" or "when i moved..."

You're talking about isolated incidents there guys. If you need to pick up a roll of tile or move a bed, call a friend with a pick-up truck or go down to u-haul and rent one locally. Unless you pick up flooring and move beds on a weekly basis, you'll make out OK. And if you do need to move big **** on a regular basis, i guess you need a truck

Also funny is the "i can put my mounatin bike in there" Whoopty ****ing doo. I can put my mountain bike on a rack on the back of my GTO. And i'm not ripping up my carpets and interior panels and tracking dirt into my car when i do so.

As for taking it to the track, a nice trunk with fold down seats should easily fit a pair of tires in it. Oh yeah, and in this scenario the tires are much lower in the car so when you slam on the brakes they don't fly off the deck over the gas tank and hit you in the head.
Old 07-12-2005 | 05:28 PM
  #27  
90 Z28SS's Avatar
Registered User
 
Joined: Jun 2000
Posts: 2,801
From: South Bend , IN
Re: Trunk vs. Hatch, Which one to use on 5th Gen?

Hands down trunk . I Love my Camaro , but I want a fresh non hatch design as my next new Camaro .

Like I said in another thread , GM has been very creative at configurable designs here lately . Be original(err not really since this has already been done) and make the car look like a trunk car , but have the decklid open with the rear window like a hatch . Maybe have the rear shelf fold up with it all too , it make it removeable completely when needed . Have the rear seatbacks fold flat . So you could still have the utility of a hatch but only when needed . Otherwise it would be just normal sealed trunk , and from the outside it would always look liek a trunk car .

Thats what I want
Old 07-12-2005 | 05:45 PM
  #28  
97z28/m6's Avatar
Registered User
 
Joined: Aug 2002
Posts: 3,597
From: oshawa,ontario,canada
Re: Trunk vs. Hatch, Which one to use on 5th Gen?

Originally Posted by notgetleft
I'm with this guy.


I like all the responses about "one time i picked up a roll of flooring" or "when i moved..."

You're talking about isolated incidents there guys. If you need to pick up a roll of tile or move a bed, call a friend with a pick-up truck or go down to u-haul and rent one locally. Unless you pick up flooring and move beds on a weekly basis, you'll make out OK. And if you do need to move big **** on a regular basis, i guess you need a truck

Also funny is the "i can put my mounatin bike in there" Whoopty ****ing doo. I can put my mountain bike on a rack on the back of my GTO. And i'm not ripping up my carpets and interior panels and tracking dirt into my car when i do so.

As for taking it to the track, a nice trunk with fold down seats should easily fit a pair of tires in it. Oh yeah, and in this scenario the tires are much lower in the car so when you slam on the brakes they don't fly off the deck over the gas tank and hit you in the head.
i go camping a few times a year ,i just moved a bed, i've hauled 4 tires for it,so you say a need a pick-up truck huh? so what do i use when i go to the drag or the road course(i do those as well) take a truck okay see the thing is my camaro does this already so i don't need to get a pick-up just a well designed hatchback camaro.
Old 07-12-2005 | 05:59 PM
  #29  
notgetleft's Avatar
Registered User
 
Joined: Jun 2001
Posts: 808
From: manassas, VA
Re: Trunk vs. Hatch, Which one to use on 5th Gen?

Originally Posted by 97z28/m6
i go camping a few times a year ,i just moved a bed, i've hauled 4 tires for it,so you say a need a pick-up truck huh? so what do i use when i go to the drag or the road course(i do those as well) take a truck okay see the thing is my camaro does this already so i don't need to get a pick-up just a well designed hatchback camaro.
And you can't fit your camping gear in a trunk and the backseat of a regular car? I really doubt it.

As for moving the bed, borrow a truck from a friend or rent one for < $20-30, or tie it to your roof if you're too cheap.

As for your tires, in case you didn't know, tirerack will ship directly to dealers and installers. If for some reason that won't work for you, would 2 trips back and forth to get all the tires to the shop be THAT big of a deal. Not really, but i bet you thought it sounded like a good reason.

Don't rolleyes at me just because you aren't a very good problem solver.
Old 07-12-2005 | 06:18 PM
  #30  
muckz's Avatar
Registered User
 
Joined: Oct 2000
Posts: 2,402
From: Toronto, ON Canada
Re: Trunk vs. Hatch, Which one to use on 5th Gen?

Originally Posted by notgetleft
Also funny is the "i can put my mounatin bike in there" Whoopty ****ing doo. I can put my mountain bike on a rack on the back of my GTO. And i'm not ripping up my carpets and interior panels and tracking dirt into my car when i do so.
You have a bike rack on your GTO? How about a trailer hitch?

Sheesh, all I said is that having owned Camaro hatchback, I really like it. The design is a big thing for me, but I was also thoroughly impressed with the cargo abilities. No, I dont put my bike in there every day, but often enough that having to take the front wheel off is more of a PITA. My carpets were in mint condition when I sold the Z. Having a bike rack on a car like Camaro/GTO?

As for taking it to the track, a nice trunk with fold down seats should easily fit a pair of tires in it. Oh yeah, and in this scenario the tires are much lower in the car so when you slam on the brakes they don't fly off the deck over the gas tank and hit you in the head.
Hit you in the head? First, there is the back of the seat with its headrest. Second, you need to learn how to package your goods before transporting them if they are flying as you say they are. Besides, a pair of tires may be fine, but fitting FOUR wheels effortlessly is even better



All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:55 AM.