MSD Optispark THREW ROD!!!
#16
Yeah, its alwys the last guy who worked on it's fault. Get over it man, its an unfortunate incident, and you could have stopped driving and minimized it. I know it sucks, but dont go blaming other people when you were too stupid to pull over for a rod knock. Does anybody in this world accept responsibility anymore?
Last edited by ChevyLT1Camaro94; 01-15-2009 at 06:28 AM.
#17
www.powertrainproducts.net
This place has some. In another post they say $999 shipped for a shortblock. Bump for them.
This place has some. In another post they say $999 shipped for a shortblock. Bump for them.
#18
Why continue to drive it when it was knocking. Not only continue to drive, but put the strain of passing somebody on a wounded engine? IF the mechanic messed with the factory timing setting and IF that did indeed cause the problem, the right thing to do would be to share the cost. You stated in your first post he did NOT adjust the timing screw so I think your going to have a tough time proving he did adjust it. You could always say MSD set it wrong at the factory, but I don't see that going very far. Your only hope is if the mechanic goes above and beyond and helps you out.
Something sounds fishy to me, and I bet it would to an attorney also. I would see what the mechanic will do for you (talk nice to him because I don't think you have a legal case).
Post # 10 you admit to racing the engine at the track many times.
idk, something fishy that i ran the car at the track a bunch of times NO PROBLEMS, BUT an hour after i get it back from this guy, i get wu my friend sed was piston slap, caused by the detonation, deff bad timing, i know it, that mechanic f*cked sumthin up
Post #13 you say he DID adjust the timing screw. You say ''theres gotta be something they did'' meaning you don't know what if anything they did wrong. (the way an attorney will read that statement).
im aware but if he messed with it, it wouldnt be there anymore. theres gotta be something they did to cause this
Post #1 you said he DIDN'T adjust it.
MSD Optispark THREW ROD!!!
so i had the msd opti and streetfire coil and taylor 10.4mm wires put in after my old opti went, after driving for 2 hours i got what i didnt know at the time was a ROD KNOCK. i had to get home so i continued driving and while trying to pass i threw a rod through the block. coud this be because my mechanic did NOT check the timing screw on the opti? and does anyone know the cheapest place to get an LT1 rebuilt motor or new/reman motor?
SHOOT ME!!!!
I understand that you are upset. Your going to go though the inconvenience and expense of fixing an engine that you hadn't planed having to fix. I've been there & done that. I once was on my way home from the hospital seeing my wife. I had to get home to see my 2 little kids in the Christmas play. 4 miles from home the truck (a 350 4 bolt with low miles) starting knocking. I shut it off and walked the last 4 miles home, making me late for the play, I wasn't very popular. The next day my brother & I pulled it home, tore it apart and all it needed was a .010 grind on the rod journals and a general freshen up. Had I driven it home I would have had the same problem you have now.
Something sounds fishy to me, and I bet it would to an attorney also. I would see what the mechanic will do for you (talk nice to him because I don't think you have a legal case).
Post # 10 you admit to racing the engine at the track many times.
idk, something fishy that i ran the car at the track a bunch of times NO PROBLEMS, BUT an hour after i get it back from this guy, i get wu my friend sed was piston slap, caused by the detonation, deff bad timing, i know it, that mechanic f*cked sumthin up
Post #13 you say he DID adjust the timing screw. You say ''theres gotta be something they did'' meaning you don't know what if anything they did wrong. (the way an attorney will read that statement).
im aware but if he messed with it, it wouldnt be there anymore. theres gotta be something they did to cause this
Post #1 you said he DIDN'T adjust it.
MSD Optispark THREW ROD!!!
so i had the msd opti and streetfire coil and taylor 10.4mm wires put in after my old opti went, after driving for 2 hours i got what i didnt know at the time was a ROD KNOCK. i had to get home so i continued driving and while trying to pass i threw a rod through the block. coud this be because my mechanic did NOT check the timing screw on the opti? and does anyone know the cheapest place to get an LT1 rebuilt motor or new/reman motor?
SHOOT ME!!!!
I understand that you are upset. Your going to go though the inconvenience and expense of fixing an engine that you hadn't planed having to fix. I've been there & done that. I once was on my way home from the hospital seeing my wife. I had to get home to see my 2 little kids in the Christmas play. 4 miles from home the truck (a 350 4 bolt with low miles) starting knocking. I shut it off and walked the last 4 miles home, making me late for the play, I wasn't very popular. The next day my brother & I pulled it home, tore it apart and all it needed was a .010 grind on the rod journals and a general freshen up. Had I driven it home I would have had the same problem you have now.
Last edited by pro70z28; 01-15-2009 at 08:33 AM.
#19
Why continue to drive it when it was knocking. Not only continue to drive, but put the strain of passing somebody on a wounded engine? IF the mechanic messed with the factory timing setting and IF that did indeed cause the problem, the right thing to do would be to share the cost. You stated in your first post he did NOT adjust the timing screw so I think your going to have a tough time proving he did adjust it. You could always say MSD set it wrong at the factory, but I don't see that going very far. Your only hope is if the mechanic goes above and beyond and helps you out.
Something sounds fishy to me, and I bet it would to an attorney also. I would see what the mechanic will do for you (talk nice to him because I don't think you have a legal case).
Post # 10 you admit to racing the engine at the track many times.
idk, something fishy that i ran the car at the track a bunch of times NO PROBLEMS, BUT an hour after i get it back from this guy, i get wu my friend sed was piston slap, caused by the detonation, deff bad timing, i know it, that mechanic f*cked sumthin up
Poast #13 you say he DID adjust the timing screw.
im aware but if he messed with it, it wouldnt be there anymore. theres gotta be something they did to cause this
MSD Optispark THREW ROD!!!
so i had the msd opti and streetfire coil and taylor 10.4mm wires put in after my old opti went, after driving for 2 hours i got what i didnt know at the time was a ROD KNOCK. i had to get home so i continued driving and while trying to pass i threw a rod through the block. coud this be because my mechanic did NOT check the timing screw on the opti? and does anyone know the cheapest place to get an LT1 rebuilt motor or new/reman motor?
SHOOT ME!!!!
Something sounds fishy to me, and I bet it would to an attorney also. I would see what the mechanic will do for you (talk nice to him because I don't think you have a legal case).
Post # 10 you admit to racing the engine at the track many times.
idk, something fishy that i ran the car at the track a bunch of times NO PROBLEMS, BUT an hour after i get it back from this guy, i get wu my friend sed was piston slap, caused by the detonation, deff bad timing, i know it, that mechanic f*cked sumthin up
Poast #13 you say he DID adjust the timing screw.
im aware but if he messed with it, it wouldnt be there anymore. theres gotta be something they did to cause this
MSD Optispark THREW ROD!!!
so i had the msd opti and streetfire coil and taylor 10.4mm wires put in after my old opti went, after driving for 2 hours i got what i didnt know at the time was a ROD KNOCK. i had to get home so i continued driving and while trying to pass i threw a rod through the block. coud this be because my mechanic did NOT check the timing screw on the opti? and does anyone know the cheapest place to get an LT1 rebuilt motor or new/reman motor?
SHOOT ME!!!!
CROSS UR FINGERS THAT SOMETHING GOOD HAPPENS
and hopefully i will be running 13's again this coming race season!
#21
There's always the possibility the stock Opti caused damage to the engine when it blew, when the new Opti was installed the damage may have allready been done.
Most rod knocks are inaudible when they first start, and get worse pretty quick.
I had two MSD Pro-billet's mess up on me, rotors fell off both of othem. When they let go I happen to be at WOT and high RPM, both times it happened I heard the biggest backfire ever known to man, the last time my G/friend was behind me and she said she thought I died in a fireball from flames out the pipes.. this means ignition occured when it was not suppose to since the exhaust was filling with fuel vapor from lack of combustion then one of the miss timed sparks finally set it off, this could also work at a worse time like when the piston is 1/2-3/4 of the way up the compression stroke... then BOOM when the piston is trying to compress everything...
Point here is when the Opti's let go, spark can be distributed to any cylinder at any time, either once or continuously depending how it let go, this could cause combustion WAY before it's suppose to happen (aka Detonation, spark knock, or worse) and destroy things like rod bearings, rods, pistons, head gaskets, etc.
Just throwing out all possibilities...
Most rod knocks are inaudible when they first start, and get worse pretty quick.
I had two MSD Pro-billet's mess up on me, rotors fell off both of othem. When they let go I happen to be at WOT and high RPM, both times it happened I heard the biggest backfire ever known to man, the last time my G/friend was behind me and she said she thought I died in a fireball from flames out the pipes.. this means ignition occured when it was not suppose to since the exhaust was filling with fuel vapor from lack of combustion then one of the miss timed sparks finally set it off, this could also work at a worse time like when the piston is 1/2-3/4 of the way up the compression stroke... then BOOM when the piston is trying to compress everything...
Point here is when the Opti's let go, spark can be distributed to any cylinder at any time, either once or continuously depending how it let go, this could cause combustion WAY before it's suppose to happen (aka Detonation, spark knock, or worse) and destroy things like rod bearings, rods, pistons, head gaskets, etc.
Just throwing out all possibilities...
Last edited by dookie454; 01-21-2009 at 08:08 PM.
#22
hmm, u make a very valid point and u may be right! i think u may have it perfect, i drove the car with the opti bearing shot, so it was backfiring and surging like crazy and i prolly drove about 100 miles like that (that was the soonest i cud bring the car in) and that may have been signing my death notice... well i may be getting an 05 GTO now and joining the LSx Guys haha
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Drtryder
LT1 Based Engine Tech
10
04-22-2015 04:17 PM