Scoggin Dickey CNC LT4 Heads
#16
Originally posted by SkarodoM
My point was that... a human makes a master port to be digitized. Well, all of our handported stuff is similar to that, b/c each and every port is measured so theyre consistent. You can CNC to reproduce a human's best work, or you can spend the time to measure by hand & reproduce it. 99% of the time, variances a human cannot prevent arent going to matter IMO. As far as who we work with... can't say... couple different shops at present moment & the stuff is floating around the major race series, generally at the front of the pack.. but aside from that.. cant give specifics at this point. Doesnt matter.. we're talking a $2k street head, not a $12k race setup. Most people just wont spend the time to make ports as consistent as we do... on the stuff that takes forever, we do go ahead & CNC alot of it... but it's still all finished by hand.
Still.. irrelevant for these guys IMO.
My point was that... a human makes a master port to be digitized. Well, all of our handported stuff is similar to that, b/c each and every port is measured so theyre consistent. You can CNC to reproduce a human's best work, or you can spend the time to measure by hand & reproduce it. 99% of the time, variances a human cannot prevent arent going to matter IMO. As far as who we work with... can't say... couple different shops at present moment & the stuff is floating around the major race series, generally at the front of the pack.. but aside from that.. cant give specifics at this point. Doesnt matter.. we're talking a $2k street head, not a $12k race setup. Most people just wont spend the time to make ports as consistent as we do... on the stuff that takes forever, we do go ahead & CNC alot of it... but it's still all finished by hand.
Still.. irrelevant for these guys IMO.
When you say 'measure', what do you mean by that? From what I know of ports, they are 'surfaces' which can only be measured accurately via CMM or some other expensive piece of equipment. Using a gage would only get you a ballpark similiarity to the master port the gage was made from right?
As for who you work 'with', I didn't ask. Besides, it's not like we're giving away military secrets here... ahem, C£¡ñt@N..... BTW give me a hint at some of these 'front of the pack' guys you all are supplying. NASCAR? They're all using (hand finished) CNC heads.. Richard Childress, Chapman, Hendricks, Weld Tech, the list goes on.
Thanks!
-Mindgame
#17
Believe me, dont believe me.. whaddever, but it doesnt make a whole hell of alot of difference. As far as subpar, well Weld-Tech, M2 etc, aren't what I'd call subpar. I know theyre using hand finished cnc stuff... alot of GPtech stuff from weld tech, but thats the point.. you said it yourself.. hand finished. If we get a gptech head that peaks around 381... & even though the port is a lil on the large side, end up gaining over 15cfm up top by hand, I dont care if it isnt as consistent as it was off the machine, it's going to make more power. If you're choosing heads you have to choose.. do you want CNC stuff that wont perform as well as hand ported, but will be more consistent than you need, or do you want to go fast. The gains from pushing a casting by hand are going to greatly outweigh the gains from having something that's more consistent than youll ever need IMO. Hell.. with freaky pressure wave interactions & the science behind manifolds, I dont think it matters all that much. I've ran a Zeiss Contura bridge type CMM & digitized ports before, so i am familiar with processes & capabilities, but... big deal, for anything this side of Formula1, meticulous hand porting is more than most people need, and with the core shift of production castings, will outperform CNC stuff every time. Can't mention who runs what, but.. yes.. some nascar... arca.. transam...allpro... *shrug* Thats stuff most people dont even realize exists though. Your welcome =P
#18
LT4 Heads
I was doing a search and came across this thread, i have the scoggin dickey catalog with these heads and the first advertised flow numbers are no where near what the catalog says. And these are the 2nd Version LT4 CNC heads as stated. You can find them on Page 47 and here is what it says.
LT4 Fully CNC Ported Version 2 - New !
Full port flow figures @ 28' H20
LT4 CNC Ported Version 2 -SD3287
Intake Exhaust
.100 65 49
.200 128 111
.300 184 141
.400 230 170
.500 261 178
.600 262 182
So there you go, no bull**** straight out of the catalog. Priced at 1082.50 per head.
LT4 Fully CNC Ported Version 2 - New !
Full port flow figures @ 28' H20
LT4 CNC Ported Version 2 -SD3287
Intake Exhaust
.100 65 49
.200 128 111
.300 184 141
.400 230 170
.500 261 178
.600 262 182
So there you go, no bull**** straight out of the catalog. Priced at 1082.50 per head.
#19
Are Nascar head casting patterns and cores set up so that there is additional machine stock in the ports and chambers to insure full cleanup on the CNC? It seems logical that a fully machined CNC port that is hand finished is the best of both worlds. Cost vs Performance. I would imagine that the Digitizing resolution and CNC Cusp height allowance is a trade off of time vs surface finish as well so not all CNC programs are the same.
Great discussion guys!
Steve
Great discussion guys!
Steve
#20
Re: LT4 Heads
Originally posted by scoobie30th
So there you go, no bull**** straight out of the catalog. Priced at 1082.50 per head.
So there you go, no bull**** straight out of the catalog. Priced at 1082.50 per head.
#21
Originally posted by SABLT194
Are Nascar head casting patterns and cores set up so that there is additional machine stock in the ports and chambers to insure full cleanup on the CNC? It seems logical that a fully machined CNC port that is hand finished is the best of both worlds. Cost vs Performance. I would imagine that the Digitizing resolution and CNC Cusp height allowance is a trade off of time vs surface finish as well so not all CNC programs are the same.
Great discussion guys!
Steve
Are Nascar head casting patterns and cores set up so that there is additional machine stock in the ports and chambers to insure full cleanup on the CNC? It seems logical that a fully machined CNC port that is hand finished is the best of both worlds. Cost vs Performance. I would imagine that the Digitizing resolution and CNC Cusp height allowance is a trade off of time vs surface finish as well so not all CNC programs are the same.
Great discussion guys!
Steve
And yea again, the cusp height is all about program execution time. Our machines cut at an rpm of 30,000 which makes quick work of a cylinder port. Surface finishes are better, cusp heights are smaller and prgram execution time is still less than most due to the rpm of our machines. Most are still working with 10-15,000 and are on a much more "production" oriented scheduling. That plays a big part as you suggested.
Take care
#23
TEA heads are VERY nice, they have good flowing valve job and ALL of the machine work looks good as well.
There was a post in the "advanced tech" section a few weeks back that talked about the exhaust flow #'s a little bit.
There was a post in the "advanced tech" section a few weeks back that talked about the exhaust flow #'s a little bit.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
95chwagon
Parts For Sale
4
01-13-2015 09:19 PM